Sunday, October 03, 2010

Quote of the Day: "The new [seat] design is completely insane"

Cathay Pacific aircraft at Hong Kong Internati...                 Image via Wikipedia
I'm flying Toronto - Singapore via Hong Kong on Cathay Pacific next week. Economy. I heard Cathay Pacific has some new economy seats that slide rather than recline.  Went to AirlineEquality.Com to check things out.

Doesn't look good.  Sample reviews :
Being 6'6" makes any seat difficult but to Cathay's credit, they gave me an exit row. Without this act of kindness, I would have been crippled because the new shell design (non-reclining) is completely insane. Have the cushions slide forward and describing this as the same as reclining is absurd. Your knees end up in your face - try it at home! One can only hope that these things get scrapped and a legitimate engineer designs the new ones. Cathay Pacific dropped the ball on this one and I cannot understand how it hasn't affected their rating.
* * * 
New economy seat. Absolute torture. I'm 6'4" Doesn't recline, only slouches, so you slump down and your neck is bent at a torturous angle. No support, no legroom, luckily I was in an aisle seat and could stick one leg out in the aisle. Very disappointing as the Cathay inflight service is very good. Never again.  
Maybe this explains why Cathay Pacific had the best  prices -- people want to avoid anything resembling Tortureair.

On the positive side, a 5' 1" reviewer reported she had plenty of leg room...

I'm taking a travel pillow and booking aisle so I can get up and stretch (for sleeping segments, I prefer window). Any other advice on long-haul survival strategies would be appreciated.

Then, back in about eight days and I'll let you know how I make out.


Enhanced by Zemanta

5 comments:

Dave Hodson said...

You might be in luck. I believe CP is still running the old interior on the YYZ-HKG routing. Check your booking, but if your aircraft is identified as a 77A, you will have the new sliding seat cushion, but if you're on a 773 (which I suspect you are) you will be in a traditional economy seat.

RkBall said...

Dave:

Cathay Pacific Airways Flight 827 (on Boeing 777-300)

Dave Hodson said...

If it is the 777-300, then you're good. If it turns out to be the 777-300ER (and who knows, maybe it is but they just truncated the "ER" on your itinerary), you will have the new seats.

I just checked the Cathay website, and when you do a search for flight bookings, flight 827 comes up as a 773. When you do a schedule inquiry, the same flight comes up as a 77A.

Seatguru.com is always a good site to check out seat reviews for specific seats on specific aircraft.

RkBall said...

Dave, thanks for the info.

RkBall said...

I'm going to call Cathay Pacific tomorrow and inquire.

"... nothing intellectually compelling or challenging.. bald assertions coupled to superstition... woefully pathetic"